A Physical vs. Chemical Challenge Mark as Favorite (92 Favorites)
In this activity, students will first complete a card sort to best categorize examples of change as physical or chemical change. Then they will compete in teams to identify whether given situations represent a physical change or a chemical change, or a physical or a chemical property.
Elementary School, Middle School, or High School
This activity will help prepare your students to meet the performance expectations in the following standards:
- 5-PS1-3: Make observations and measurements to identify materials based on their properties.
- MS-PS1-2: Analyze and interpret data on the properties of substances before and after the substances interact to determine if a chemical reaction has occurred.
- Scientific and Engineering Practices:
- Analyzing and Interpreting Data
By the end of this activity, students should be able to
- Determine and support if examples are physical or chemical properties.
- Determine and support if examples are physical or chemical changes.
This activity supports students’ understanding of
- Physical Properties
- Chemical Properties
- Physical Changes
- Chemical Changes
Teacher Preparation: 20 minutes
Lesson: 30 minutes
- 2 Fly-Swatters
- Student Sorting Cards (1 set per group)
- One set of Game Show Cards
- Following materials for Demo Clues
- Ice Cube
- 3 Clear cups or beakers
- Rubbing alcohol
- 2 Pie pans
- Effervescent tablet
- Baking soda
- Piece of paper
- Paper Clips
- Pencil sharpener
- Always wear safety goggles when handling chemicals in the lab.
- Students should wash their hands thoroughly before leaving the lab.
- When students complete the lab, instruct them how to clean up their materials and dispose of any chemicals.
- Always use caution around open flames. Keep flames away from flammable substances.
- Always be aware of an open flame. Do not reach over it, tie back hair, and secure loose clothing.
- Open flames can cause burns. Liquid wax is hot and can burn the skin.
- Exercise caution when using a heat source. Hot plates should be turned off and unplugged as soon as they are no longer needed.
- When lighting the match and wooden splint, be cautious with the flame.
- An operational fire extinguisher should be in the classroom.
- There are two different parts to this activity. Part 1, “Sorting Cards” can be used as an introduction to a lesson on physical and chemical changes. Part 2, is a Game Show review style team challenge of the concepts learned.
- Print one set of sorting cards for each table group of students in your class. For example, I have nine tables of 3-4 students, so I print off nine sets of cards. The teacher can prepare the sorting cards by cutting them apart and putting them in envelopes to be distributed to teams or can have the teams cut them apart.
- Give teams 5-10 minutes to sort them into two piles: Physical Properties and Chemical Properties. After all teams have their cards sorted, go through cards as a class to see if students properly placed them.
|Answers to Card Sort|
|Physical Changes||Chemical Changes|
Game Show Review:
- Print one set of the clue cards on cardstock or paste on cardstock. This is a great review after concepts have been introduced and can be used in a variety of ways. Some suggestions and variations are:
- Students sit (or stand depending on height of table) face to face across from each other with flyswatters perpendicular to the table.Put an “X” or sticker on the table beforehand. When the clue is read by the teacher, the student who smacks the “X” first gets to answer the question for their team.If they answer incorrectly, then the other person gets to try.The flyswatters are a fun way to simulate buzzers and keeps things light-hearted.
- Points are awarded for correct answers.The teacher can award a point for the correct answer and an additional point when students can support their answer choice.(Additional point is an optional modification to game)
- Options for Choosing Teams: Deciding teams can be a challenge. Sometimes it is hard to get everyone to participate and the same students want to keep coming up to play.But here are some options:
- Boys vs. Girls
- One side of room vs. Other side
- Two different colored slips of paper that are numbered 1 through 15 (if you have 30 students) randomly distributed to students. The color represents the team, the number represents the contestant number and who they are competing against.This is MY favorite method that ensures everyone participates.
- Prizes can be awarded to winning teams, but I like to have students put their names on their color-number slips of paper and do drawings at the end for prizes.
- Preparation for the Demo Clues: Put demo materials behind a cardboard barrier so students can’t see what is being prepared, then reveal the clue to students in a fun-surprising manner.I like to remain silent during demos to allow students to process what is going on.
- Ice Cube Melts: Just hold an ice cube in your hand as it melts and say nothing!
- Salt dissolve in water: Say nothing as you pour some salt in a cup of water and stir it.
- A substance burns : Light a match, or light a butane/handheld lighter.
- Effervescent Tablet : Drop tablet into clear cup with water and say nothing.
- Baking soda & vinegar : Pour a small amount of vinegar to some baking soda already put in a cup.
- Crumpling a paper : With all the dramatics and flare that a teacher can provide, crumple a piece of paper!
- Magnet and paper clips : Put some paper clips on the table where the contestants are sitting and pick them up using a magnet.
- Sharpening a pencil : I like silently using a hand-held sharpener with intense and deliberate concentration.
- Discussion: Many of these clues spark some clarifying discussions with students. Use this opportunity to clear up misunderstandings.
- Optional: Have students complete an Exit Ticket (Ex: 3-2-1: Three examples of physical changes, two examples of chemical changes, one question you still have.)Or have students explain when a change occurs, how they know if it is a physical change or chemical change.
For the Student
A physical change only changes the shape or form of a substance. During a chemical change, the original substance is changed into something new.
As a group categorize the examples written on cards in the most appropriate category. Which examples represent physical changes? Which represent chemical changes?
- Cut the cards apart.
- As a group, sort them into two piles:
- Physical Changes
- Chemical Changes
Share your results with your class, and record your results below:
|Examples of Physical Changes||Examples of Chemical Changes|
- Which examples were easy to determine?
- Which ones were difficult? What made them difficult?
- How can you determine if a physical change or chemical change has occurred?